NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Thursday refused to allow Muharram processions across the country, observing it may lead to chaos and targeting of a particular community for spreading Covid-19.
The bench, headed by CJI SA Bobde, emphasised that such generic directions cannot be issued in exercise of Article 32 of the Constitution and declined to entertain a PIL by Syed Kalbe Jawad, a Shia cleric from Lucknow who sought permission for Muharram processions in a limited manner amid pandemic.
“You are asking for a general order and then if we allow this, there will be chaos. Particular community will be targetted for spreading Covid. We as a court cannot risk the health of all the people,” the bench told Jawad, asking him to move the Allahabad High Court with his plea.
As the petitioner’s lawyer sought to refer to the Supreme Court’s order allowing Jagannath Puri Rath Yatra, the bench said that case was an entirely different one.
“Jagannath Puri case was one specific place where Rath was to go from point A to point B. If it was one specific place, we can assess the danger and so we passed that order. That is not the case here,” CJI said.
Petitioner also referred to the court’s recent decision of allowing three Jain temples in Mumbai to open during the Paryushan festival.
“In both, the petitioners had limited prayers. We cannot pass general directions. Ganesh Chaturthi was not allowed in Tamil Nadu. We cannot pass general orders. It is not possible to give general directions,” added the bench.